A Deed of Variation (DoV), also known as a deed of family arrangement, is a legal document used to modify the distribution of a deceased person's estate. When someone passes away, their estate is typically distributed according to their Will. However, if no Will exists, the Rules of Intestacy apply. In either scenario, a Deed of Variation provides flexibility for beneficiaries to redistribute assets. Despite its utility, this legal tool is not without contention. In this blog, we'll delve into what a Deed of Variation is, why it might be used, and the circumstances under which it can be challenged.
A Deed of Variation allows beneficiaries to legally alter the distribution of a deceased person's estate. It is particularly helpful in cases where the terms of a Will or intestacy rules do not meet the needs of the beneficiaries or align with their wishes.
For example, a beneficiary may choose to redirect part or all of their inheritance to another person, often for tax planning purposes or to address perceived inequities in the estate distribution.
This legal mechanism does not amend the Will itself; instead, it changes how the estate is administered. Any changes made must have the agreement of all affected beneficiaries. This can include heirs named in the Will or individuals entitled under the Rules of Intestacy if no Will exists.
Furthermore, a Deed of Variation must be executed within two years of the date of death to qualify for any tax benefits. If the terms are agreed upon and all legal requirements are met, the document becomes binding, making its terms enforceable.
There are several reasons why a Deed of Variation might be necessary. In some cases, it is used to address ambiguities or oversights in the Will.
For instance, a Deed of Variation can rectify the situation if the deceased person unintentionally omitted someone they intended to provide for, such as a dependent or close family member. Similarly, it can be employed to redistribute assets more equitably, ensuring all beneficiaries feel fairly treated.
Tax planning is another common reason for using a Deed of Variation. Inheritance tax (IHT) can be a significant burden on an estate, with rates as high as 40% on estates exceeding the nil-rate band. By redirecting assets to other individuals or organisations, a Deed of Variation can reduce the overall IHT liability. For instance, a beneficiary might redirect their share of the estate to their children, effectively skipping a generation and avoiding additional IHT if they were to pass away shortly after receiving their inheritance.
In some cases, a Deed of Variation is used to distribute assets in a way that reduces capital gains tax (CGT) liabilities.
By redistributing certain assets more strategically, beneficiaries can minimise the tax implications of future sales. However, while these tax benefits can be appealing, they also bring complexity. Poorly drafted Deeds of Variation can lead to unintended tax consequences, making it crucial to seek expert advice before proceeding.
Although a Deed of Variation offers many benefits, it is not immune to challenges. Various circumstances can lead to disputes over its validity, including procedural errors, disagreements among beneficiaries, or concerns about coercion or undue influence.
One of the most straightforward ways to challenge a Deed of Variation is for a beneficiary to refuse to sign. As the document requires the consent of all affected parties, a single dissenting voice can block its implementation. This often occurs when a beneficiary feels the changes would unfairly disadvantage them or if they disagree with the motivations behind the variation.
In addition to refusal, procedural errors can undermine the validity of a Deed of Variation. For the document to be legally enforceable, it must be correctly executed. This includes ensuring that all required signatures are present and that witnessing requirements are met. If these formalities are not adhered to, the document can be rendered invalid, opening the door to legal challenges.
Another common ground for contesting a Deed of Variation is the lack of informed consent. Beneficiaries must fully understand the implications of the variation before agreeing to it. If a beneficiary was misled, pressured, or coerced into signing, the variation may be challenged on the grounds of undue influence. Courts take such allegations seriously and may invalidate the document if the evidence supports the claim.
Furthermore, a Deed of Variation may be challenged if it disproportionately disadvantages one or more beneficiaries. For instance, if the variation significantly alters the original distribution of the estate without a clear justification, the affected beneficiaries may seek to contest it.
Similarly, if a beneficiary lacks the mental capacity to provide informed consent, the variation cannot proceed without court approval. The court will only approve such variations if they are deemed to be in the best interests of the incapacitated beneficiary.
While a Deed of Variation can reduce tax liabilities, it cannot be used to evade creditors or manipulate access to means-tested benefits.
For example, if a beneficiary attempts to use the deed to redirect assets while avoiding repayment of personal debts, creditors may challenge the validity of the document.
Likewise, if the variation is seen as an attempt to artificially reduce income or assets to qualify for state benefits, the authorities may intervene.
It is also important to note that a Deed of Variation must include specific tax declarations to ensure it is recognised for tax purposes.
If these declarations are missing or incorrectly drafted, the variation may not achieve the intended tax benefits. In some cases, this can lead to additional tax liabilities for the estate or beneficiaries, prompting disputes among the parties involved.
Given the complexities involved, professional advice is essential when creating a Deed of Variation.
A solicitor can ensure that the document is correctly drafted, properly executed, and legally compliant. They can also provide guidance on potential tax implications, helping beneficiaries avoid unintended consequences.
For example, a poorly worded Deed of Variation might inadvertently trigger additional IHT or CGT liabilities. Similarly, failing to address all beneficiaries' concerns during the drafting process can lead to disputes, potentially derailing the entire variation.
By seeking expert advice early, beneficiaries can navigate these challenges and achieve a more equitable and tax-efficient distribution of the estate.
Once a Deed of Variation has been signed and executed, it is final. Unlike a Will, which can be amended or revoked during the testator's lifetime, a Deed of Variation cannot be altered once it has been executed.
This underscores the importance of careful planning and drafting. Beneficiaries must fully consider the implications of the variation, as there are no second chances to amend it once it is legally binding.
A Deed of Variation is a powerful tool for modifying the distribution of a deceased person's estate. It can address inequities, provide for overlooked individuals, and offer significant tax advantages. However, the process is not without its challenges. Beneficiaries may refuse to sign, procedural errors can invalidate the document, and disputes over consent or fairness can lead to legal challenges.
To minimise the risk of disputes, it is crucial to seek expert legal advice when drafting and executing a Deed of Variation. A solicitor can help ensure the document is legally sound, tax-efficient, and acceptable to all parties involved. With proper guidance, a Deed of Variation can provide a fair and effective solution for managing an estate, benefiting both current and future generations.
If you're considering a Deed of Variation or need advice on managing an estate, Premier Solicitors is here to help. Our experienced team of legal professionals can guide you through the process, ensuring your document is legally compliant and protects your interests.
Whether you're looking to address ambiguities, minimise tax liabilities, or ensure fairness among beneficiaries, we provide expert advice tailored to your unique circumstances.
For more information, please call us on 01234 358 080 or visit our contact page to send an enquiry form.
Read more blog posts which Amuneek has written for this website.
