Contentious probate refers to disputes that can arise directly after a death or during the administration of a deceased person's estate, involving disagreements over the validity of a Will, its interpretation, and the distribution of assets. Understanding the key issues and legal frameworks in contentious probate is essential for anyone involved in or planning for estate management, as it helps navigate these complex and often emotionally charged situations effectively.
Contentious probate disputes can occur between beneficiaries, Executors, and other interested parties and typically involve issues related to the validity of a Will, the interpretation of its terms, and the distribution of the estate's assets. Contentious probate occurs when there are disagreements or suspicions about the fairness, legality, or accuracy of the Will or the actions of those responsible for managing the estate. Such disputes between grieving parties can often become very volatile, very quickly, as they involve family members and close relations.
Contentious probate disputes can involve a variety of parties, including beneficiaries named in the Will, potential heirs not named in the Will, Executors or Administrators of the estate, and other interested parties such as creditors. A Caveat can be applied to an Estate by an applicant who may have concerns about the Estate administration; the conduct of Executors or Trustees; or the validity of a Will, the Caveat will place the administration on hold whilst any irregularities and concerns can be investigated by a contested probate solicitor.
Family members are often central to these disputes, but friends, business associates, or charities named in the Will may also be involved. Essentially, anyone with a legitimate interest or claim in the estate can become involved in a contentious probate matter.
The cost of contentious probate can vary significantly depending on the complexity of the dispute, the value of the estate, and the length of the legal process. Costs typically include legal fees for solicitors and barristers, court fees, and additional expenses such as expert witness fees or costs for gathering evidence.
Mediation, which is often encouraged as a less adversarial and potentially cheaper alternative to court proceedings, also incurs fees. In some cases, the court may order the estate to pay the legal costs, but it is also possible for the losing party to be ordered to cover the costs. Because contentious probate can become expensive, it's advisable to seek expert legal advice early to understand potential costs and explore ways to resolve disputes efficiently.
Common issues in contentious probate include a caveat being placed on the Estate for varying reasons, challenges to the validity of the Will, disputes over the interpretation of the Will's terms, and disagreements about the administration and the role of the Executors not acting in the best interests of the Estate or the Beneficiaries and disputes over the distribution of the estate's assets or disputes over occupation of a deceased property following the death.
Validity challenges may arise from claims that the deceased lacked the mental capacity to make a valid Will, or may have been unduly influenced by others, or that the Will was forged or fraudulently created. Additionally, conflicts can occur if there are ambiguities in the Will's language; or there are doubts around the circumstances of the Testator signing and persons that acted as witnesses to the Will signing or if the Will fails to adequately provide for certain family members or dependents.
The validity of a Will can be challenged on several grounds, including lack of testamentary capacity, undue influence, fraud, or improper execution. Lack of testamentary capacity means that the deceased did not have the mental ability to understand the nature of making a Will, the extent of their estate, or the claims of those who might expect to benefit.
Undue influence involves situations where the deceased was forced, coerced or manipulated into making decisions about their Will that they would not have made otherwise. These challenges often require substantial evidence, including medical records, witness testimony, and expert opinions.
If a Will is believed to be forged, fraudulently created, or improperly executed, interested parties can contest the Will by filing a claim in the Probate Registry or the High Court. Evidence must be presented to support these claims, such as handwriting analysis to detect forgery, witness statements to verify the circumstances under which the Will was created, and documentation to prove that the Will was not signed and witnessed according to legal requirements. Legal advice and representation are crucial in these cases to navigate the complexities of probate law and present a compelling case.
Issues regarding the interpretation of a Will typically arise when the language used in the document is unclear or ambiguous, leading to different interpretations by the beneficiaries or Executors. These ambiguities can cause significant disputes, especially if they affect the distribution of substantial assets.
To resolve ambiguities, the court may consider extrinsic evidence, such as the deceased's previous statements, the context in which the Will was drafted, and other relevant documents. The primary aim is to ascertain the true intentions of the testator and ensure that these intentions are honoured as closely as possible.
The Inheritance (Provision for Family and Dependants) Act 1975 allows certain individuals to apply for reasonable financial provision from a deceased person's estate if they believe they have not been adequately provided for.
Those eligible to make a claim under the Act include the deceased's spouse or civil partner, former spouses or civil partners who have not remarried, children, any person treated as a child of the family, and any person who was financially maintained by the deceased. These claims are time-specific and must be made within six months from the date of the Grant of Probate. The court considers several factors when deciding these claims, including the applicant's financial needs, the size of the estate, and the nature of the relationship with the deceased.
Disputes between Executors, beneficiaries, and trustees often arise from disagreements over the management and distribution of the estate's assets. Beneficiaries may allege that Executors or trustees have breached their fiduciary duties, acted negligently, or mismanaged the estate. Allegations of mismanagement can include failing to keep accurate records, delaying the distribution of assets, or making unauthorised transactions.
To address these issues, affected parties can seek legal recourse by applying to the court for the removal of the Executor or trustee, or for an order requiring them to account for their actions and compensate for any losses incurred.
When a person dies without a valid Will, their estate is distributed according to the rules of intestacy, as outlined in the Administration of Estates Act 1925. These rules prioritise close family members, such as spouses, children, and parents, in a specific order of inheritance.
Disputes in intestacy cases often arise when family members disagree on their entitlements, or when individuals who were financially dependent on the deceased but are not recognised under intestacy rules seek provision from the estate. These disputes can be complex and emotionally charged, requiring careful navigation through the legal framework governing intestate succession.
Seeking expert legal advice in contentious probate matters is crucial because these disputes involve complex legal principles and procedures that require specialised knowledge. An experienced probate lawyer can provide valuable guidance, help gather necessary evidence, and represent parties effectively in court or during mediation.
Understanding contentious probate is also essential for estate planning and management, as it highlights the importance of drafting clear, legally sound Wills and considering the needs of all potential beneficiaries. By addressing these issues proactively, individuals can minimise the risk of disputes and ensure their estate is distributed according to their wishes.
If you need professional assistance, Premier Solicitors, a leading UK law firm, offers expert and affordable legal services in Probate (Contentious and Non-contentious) and Estate Administration. For more information, please call us on 01234 358 080 or visit our contact page to send an enquiry form.
Read more blog posts which Emma has written for this website.
